When a child is diagnosed with autism, parents face many critical decisions, one of the most important being where to seek therapy. Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) is widely recognized as an effective treatment for autism, but should it be delivered in a clinic-based setting or a school-based program?
The answer largely depends on the child's communication abilities, behavioral needs, and readiness for a school environment. In general, nonverbal children tend to benefit more from intensive clinic-based ABA, while verbal children may thrive with school-based support. Let’s explore why.
Why Clinic-Based ABA is Best for Nonverbal Children
1. Intensive, Individualized Therapy
Nonverbal children often require one-on-one, highly structured therapy to develop foundational communication skills.
Clinic-based ABA provides:
A low therapist-to-child ratio, ensuring individualized attention.
Frequent real-time adjustments to treatment plans based on progress.
A controlled environment free from the distractions of a busy classroom.
Studies show that early intensive ABA (25+ hours per week) leads to better language and social outcomes, particularly for nonverbal children who need direct instruction in functional communication skills.
2. Communication-Focused Interventions
For nonverbal children, learning to communicate is the top priority.
Clinic-based therapy provides specialized interventions such as:
Verbal Behavior Therapy (VBT) to encourage speech and language development.
Augmentative and Alternative Communication (AAC) training, including Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS) and speech-generating devices.
Structured opportunities for social interaction in small groups before transitioning to larger environments.
3. Effective Behavior Management
Many nonverbal children struggle with self-injurious behaviors (SIBs) or aggression due to difficulties expressing their needs.
Clinic-based therapy allows for:
Immediate, consistent implementation of behavior intervention plans (BIPs).
More structured reinforcement strategies to reduce problem behaviors.
A team of BCBAs and therapists who can address behavioral challenges in real-time.
4. Prepares Children for School Readiness
Before transitioning into a school setting, nonverbal children need to develop essential classroom readiness skills, such as:
Sitting and attending to group instruction.
Following multi-step directions.
Transitioning between activities.
A clinic-based setting helps build these foundational abilities, ensuring a smoother transition to school when the child is ready.
Why School-Based ABA is Ideal for Verbal Children
1. Natural Peer Interaction & Social Learning
Verbal children often benefit from structured social learning opportunities with neurotypical peers.
In a school setting, they can:
Practice conversational skills in real-world environments (e.g., classrooms, playgrounds).
Develop turn-taking, sharing, and group participation skills.
Learn through peer modeling, which has been shown to improve social engagement.
2. Integration of Academics and Therapy
Unlike clinics, schools provide access to both academic instruction and therapy services, allowing verbal children to:
Receive ABA support within their classroom.
Work on executive functioning skills alongside educational content.
Learn adaptive behaviors that help them navigate a school environment independently.
3. Cost-Effective and Legally Protected Services
School-based ABA is often provided at no cost under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). For families facing financial barriers, this can be a more accessible option than private, clinic-based ABA therapy.
4. Promotes Generalization of Skills
While clinics focus on controlled, structured learning, school-based ABA encourages children to apply skills in dynamic, real-world settings. This can be especially beneficial for verbal children who need to:
Adapt to changing environments.
Learn independence in daily school routines.
Develop problem-solving skills in unstructured social situations.
Final Recommendation:
Clinic First, School When Ready
For nonverbal children (ages 3-5), clinic-based ABA is often the best choice. The intensive therapy, communication focus, and behavior management strategies provided in a clinic prepare children for later success in school.
For verbal children, school-based ABA offers an effective way to integrate social, academic, and behavioral learning in the environment.
In my view and based on my experience, schools are effective in offering general ABA implementation through special education teachers, assistants, and one-to-one aides. However, there is a lack of consistent oversight by a BCBA. In the school environment, BCBAs are typically overwhelmed with a large caseload and are not held to the same standards as in clinics, where insurance company requirements guide them and place them under strict guidelines. While legal aspects exist in schools, many families with IEPs will tell you that certain parts of their IEPs were not implemented due to staffing shortages, among other reasons, and it rarely reaches the point of legal action. Parents must advocate vigorously to secure all necessary services for their children. Conversely, in a clinic setting, families often face financial burdens due to co-pays required by their insurance. As a result, schools may be one of the few affordable options for families. Last, while the school environment provides a more natural setting, we at Lotus strive to provide trauma-informed, positive behavior support in a naturalistic format to meet and exceed the need for naturalistic intervention while maintaining intervention integrity. Naturalistic interventions are growing and expanding the ABA community, providing more trauma-informed care in clinical settings.
In summary, each form of ABA delivery has its advantages and disadvantages. The ideal setting ultimately depends on the child's individual needs, developmental progress, and therapy objectives. Consulting with a Board Certified Behavior Analyst (BCBA) can assist families in determining the best approach to enhance their child’s potential. At Lotus, we collaborate with families to ensure their PREFERENCES and needs are met while striving to offer the maximum amount of ABA therapy hours. We offer flexible scheduling, allowing parents to create hybrid schedules incorporating school and therapy. We provide copay discounts to support families in need and offer after-school scheduling.
Ultimately, no single setting is better than another. You need to decide what suits your family best, taking into account various factors like financial situation, severity level, location, work schedule, and more. This blog seeks to inform and encourage discussions, hold our private practice and schools accountable for their service delivery, and offer my clinical perspective as a BCBA with experience in diverse settings. Ideally, professionals should collaborate, regardless of the setting, to ensure children receive comprehensive and integrated care plans that address all their needs and alleviate the strain on the family unit, enhancing the overall quality of life for the entire family.
Disclaimer: I am only discussing ABA therapy in clinics vs. schools, no other forms of therapy.
Kommentare